'All Hat, No Cattle' – Marketing Objectives and Strategies Without KPIs

In marketing, establishing the right objectives and strategies is crucial for success. Whether you're launching a new product, finding new customers, or increasing sales through your current customer base, your marketing efforts need to be SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-based).

Of these five criteria, Measurability, expressed as Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), may be the most important. Actionless objectives can be weak and opaque if they are not accompanied by meaningful KPIs. In other words, "All Hat, No Cattle."

KPIs add the necessary granularity, offering insights into specific aspects of your campaign performance. While objectives illuminate what we want to do, their accompanying KPIs define the quantifiable metrics that help track progress toward meeting the marketing objectives.

Marketing objectives also serve as the compass for your sales and marketing teams. They articulate the overarching directions for your strategies. These objectives provide focus, align teams, and set the stage for measuring success. From acquiring new customers to boosting sales, objectives define the destination.

Many marketing objectives are well-written and well-intentioned, but without a KPI offering measurement, timing, and accountability, they ring hollow. For example, here’s a good marketing objective. But where does it lead and what is the time frame?

“Increase online sales through targeted social media campaigns, optimizing website user experience, and implementing a referral program."

So why write a marketing objective without a KPI showing the monetary and timing end goals? It has been my experience, working from both the agency and client sides of the business, that the lack of insightful information about costs and required resources to achieve an objective’s KPI is usually at fault.

For example, it’s easy to say, “Increase our online sales by 25% within 12 months.” But, at what cost and is the corporate commitment and resolve there to provide the resources to back up the goal? And what is the ROI to achieve the objective?

Marketing departments and agencies cannot work in a vacuum, detached from the managerial and financial functions of the company. In the planning process, there must be functional alignments and full sharing of plans and directions for marketing objectives to be on target, meet their KPI promises, and achieve ROI.

Here are a few examples of marketing objectives with explicit KPIs. In each of these cases, KPIs and objectives create a symbiotic relationship, each reinforcing the other. KPIs provide a reality check, allowing you to gauge whether your strategies are effective in moving the needle toward your objectives or if adjustments are needed.

New Customer Conquest

Marketing Objective: Sell Product A to 200 new conquest customers (currently using competitive products) by the end of the year.

Marketing Strategy: Create a comprehensive plan of marketing tactics to generate and qualify new customer leads and move prospects toward interest, evaluation, and purchase.

Improve Sales to Existing Customers

Marketing Objective: Grow sales by 25% to existing customers by the end of the year.

Marketing Strategy: Develop various marketing tactics focused on current customers to improve loyalty and encourage more frequent purchases.

Launch a New Product

Marketing Objective: Launch and sell 10,000 of the new XYZ product by the end of the year.

Marketing Strategy 1: Launch the new XYZ product into the marketplace by developing and implementing marketing tactics that will fill the distribution pipeline.

Marketing Strategy 2: Deploy various pull-through marketing tactics to drive sales and store traffic to sellers of the new XYZ Product.

Develop Qualified Leads and New Customers

Marketing Objective: Increase qualified leads by 500 and close new business to 50 new customers within the next 12 months.

Marketing Strategy: Utilize a combination of incentives, digital marketing, and direct contact marketing tactics to generate qualified leads and close sales on new leads.

Grow a Dealer Network

Marketing Objective: Add 200 dealers to the network, with common branding and marketing, to generate a 33% sales increase within two years.

Marketing Strategy 1: Implement a broad range of marketing tactics including communications materials, incentives and pricing plans, meetings, and events to build a network of 200 dealers.

Marketing Strategy 2: Provide dealers with the marketing tools to drive store traffic and increase sales through attractive product offers, merchandising, pull-through advertising, high levels of customer service, and training.

Tracking Progress and Adapting Strategies

Regularly tracking KPIs against objectives is imperative. Data-driven insights empower marketers to adapt strategies in real-time, allocating resources where they will have the most impact.

A well-crafted marketing plan sets clear objectives and strategies to inspire action and defines KPIs and ROI to measure that action's success. Without KPIs, marketing objectives are like a dude cowboy – “All Hat, No Cattle.”

Want More Marketing Tips and Ideas?

Go to Marketing Convergence Solutions for practical ways to align sales and marketing to help you strategically generate more sales, leads, and customer loyalty.